For
work places education becomes training, mostly set courses with
segmented syllabuses of what the worker needs or is required to know
to do their job. Some training has national standards like health and
safety where courses are regulated and training is mandatory. These
tend to be inflexible in that they are a set syllabus in set hours.
Actual delivery of training is hit and miss with many factors
reducing any effectiveness of training that could enhance performance
in the topic or larger employment. For many this required training is
not understood however clear the law or documentation is. The ability
to make up ‘regulations’ on the spot or some excuse or power play
is human nature and an interesting study unless you want a safe
environment or help when something goes wrong.
So
the first barriers are
workplace ignorance, alternative focus (get their job done or get
paid) and general disorganisation. Courses on site are constantly
interrupted and mobiles need to to be off. Wanting to finish early to
go to a meeting an appointment or pick up the kids is regular.
Training is most definitely a lower concern let alone how to train
effectively. Perceptions of learning and
training are usually based on
appearance and videos regardless of actual quality. Courses are made
up of mixed students in terms of ability and experience. I have had
people with over 20 years experience on a longer beginner course as
their work had not put them on the right course to keep them in date
as well as
people with English as a second language. The courses are often set
in terms of time and syllabus regardless of actual need.
Teaching
involves taking the learners from where they start in terms of
knowledge, skills etc. to the required standard. Some start the
course at the required standard and some need more time or support
(sometimes more than available)
to reach standards. There is a
gap between training assessment and real world performance as the
real world is rarely organised and prepared so adapting to
circumstance and avoiding consequences are the major tasks for many.
Short term responsiveness is the norm and standards are low.
Improvement
in this situation is paramount but regardless training needs to be
more effective and useful and of
course used. Training where
someone stands at the front and reads a long Power-point
slide is accepted in most professional courses even in schools where
the same methods would fail inspection if performed by teachers. The
ideas that have formed understanding are reflected in the words used.
Educate comes from the Latin root ‘to lead’. Coach is from the
idea of taking someone from one place to another. Training needs to
take these (original) ideas on board. Leading classes and people to
higher understanding and abilities and taking people from ignorance
and inability to knowledge and ability. The next stage is to apply
the higher knowledge and skills to the real world. I have received
award winning training that just did not reflect the actual work
place, I have struggled to remain awake and seen many fall asleep. I
have seen many battle with acronyms that are not the required
knowledge but a way of remembering, they are then tested on the
acronym. None of this is learning or revision or educating or
coaching. It is a waste of time telling people things they already
know, you could always just ask them, write their correct answers on
a board and then move on to something they do not know or can
improve. Some training and trainers insist on a certain acronym
rather than the general answer and claim it is the answer. Much
training just ticks boxes.
To
improve
training must use the research that has been done and methods that
have proved to be effective. Focusing on the most important elements
for beginners and then gradually adding useful details rather than
insisting on minor points claimed as important. Linking areas
together, relating to the real world occurrence and to existing
knowledge and experience all move understanding to higher levels.
Traditionally stories have been used so real world examples carry
this on, but also a narrative of actions in situations general and
specific create a frame work (linkage) to work first the general
ideas and then more detail as the frame and over view is understood.
Separate elements with no connection are easily forgotten. Working
from known and simple then developing to more complicated and
specific is an organisational method that keeps progression
(narrative). Rather than sudden isolated statements with little
relevance. Too much ‘showing off’ of higher (pseudo) knowledge or
experience is not for learning but teachers ego. This can be
de-motivating if too advanced for learners or lead learners to
attempt too advanced tasks for their own knowledge and skills.
Experience
needs to be factored outside of just the course. Practice of skills
and refreshing of knowledge. In first aid sometimes a first aider may
have to perform in an emergency almost 3 years after their last
training course. Are their skills really supposed to be good? Will
they even be confident to try and help? Physical skills like CPR or
bandages need to be practised over several weeks and regularly not
once every 3 years which is just not effective and leads to low
performance (yes poor CPR or un-attempted will not work!). Sports
people and musicians practice a lot to reach high standards this
pattern needs to be appropriately transposed to work training.
For
many the use of pre existing knowledge can be used as a metaphor or a
base to aid understanding. Children and young people may not have
direct knowledge or experience to pin onto. Pre employment education
needs to develop experience and knowledge up to required levels it
cannot be completely disconnected from work (and society)
environments. Much of education is perceived as irrelevant to the
children and their lives and although it is not the perception is a
barrier to motivation and attention. Teaching relevant skills and
experiences need to be included especially for children from
backgrounds different to the teachers.
No comments:
Post a Comment