Why
the question mark? Well it's a label that is different in meaning to
what actually happens. As this counts as my main subject I better
discuss this first.
Here
education has a massive overlap with health. I work with the general
ideas that prevention is better than cure (medical), and that getting
things right first time (business), or the beginning is everything
(philosophy). Another idea is the importance of habits and working
towards the positive and away from the negative ones. Trying to
correct a problem say in adults is harder, more expensive (time,
money etc.) and a lot less successful than early in life.
I
will take two perspectives with PE. The first is for the majority. If
9 out of 10 adults do not exercise enough and half not at all, is
that a measure of success for PE and education. They do not have
positive habits and any result less than half, cannot be seen as a
measure of success. This measure must be given to PE (and others) to
improve. Not exercising and being inactive is one of the major
factors in many bad health outcomes. 3 out of 4 people die of Heart
Attack, Cancer and Stroke. Exercise is positive in
prevention/delaying these and actually generally many illnesses, and
of course death (hopefully this registers as serious (grave)).
Exercise has been found as positive even in people suffering from
many illnesses and conditions. It also has been found to help other
areas.
But
it's not just the most common causes of death (these do not come
cheap!). The most common reason for taking more than 3 days of work
is back pain, a big factor is incorrect lifting technique, if only
there was a sport/activity called weightlifting (boy am I holding
back so much sarcasm, well most of the time!) where these skills
could be taught. Many sports/physical activities have essential
skills that are not even attempted to be taught let alone corrected
and developed. Many sports injuries (well they get a good habit and
then go and ruin it) are bad technique especially the exercise
(fitness) element, running and weight training are classic destroyers
of joints. Competitive sports have as the number one cause of injury
as 'foul play'. Too busy competing and not actually improving or
learning (the E in PE stands for education).
These
are all quite visible and clear. Mental health is greatly influenced
by physical health and hence physical activity. What's the best
stress relief – No it's not alcohol, unhealthy food, smoking, drugs
(illegal or medical). Of course if you thought of one so far
unmentioned thing, I am counting that as physical activity, but will
not be including that within physical education, although that course
may be more popular and commercially successful.
As
many people hated PE at school they were not catered for at all.
Making PE educational, and enjoyable will improve participation in
adults (work allowing), improve their life (less ill health and
problems) and cost the nation less.
The
other end (another perspective) for PE is the elite level. The recent
sporting success for Britain (Olympics etc.) has mainly been by
privately educated (7% of children but over half of medals) and
outside clubs and facilities.
So
the question is what is PE in education doing? Well I can tell you
teachers are working many hours going to many meetings, covering
other areas, completing paperwork. They are not educating children,
giving them positive experience and preparing children for life.
Actually many PE teachers come from team sports backgrounds and their
preparation for coaching skills and exercise is often lacking
especially outside their sport. Some can do but many follow official
lesson planning and bureaucracy. Encouraging and helping children not
like them, the PE haters, is a difficult jump. Preparing long term
excellence is not possible in classes of 30, 40 plus. So they are
good (or not) at crowd management and problem avoidance (from above).
No comments:
Post a Comment